How to compare contractor quotes in Pakistan with a BOQ
Three contractors have quoted for the same 5-marla house in Lahore. One says PKR 5.2 million for grey structure, another says PKR 6.4 million, and the third gives you a single lump-sum number written on the back of a visiting card. Which is the "cheap" one, and which is the "expensive" one? You cannot know until you break each quote into its parts.
A bill of quantities, or BOQ, is how you do that. It is nothing more than a line-by-line list of the work and materials, with quantities and rates. Once you insist on one, you can compare contractor quotes line by line, and the corners being cut become visible.
Why a lump-sum quote is a warning, not a price
A single number tells you nothing about what is inside it. A contractor who quotes PKR 1,900 per square foot for grey structure may be including 40 bags of cement less per floor than the one who quotes PKR 2,200. You will only find out when the work stops halfway and a "variation" bill arrives.
In my experience, the biggest gap between quotes is almost never labour. It is the material specification: steel grade, cement brand, brick quality, the thickness of slabs, the depth of foundations. Those choices decide whether your building is sound and whether your costs stay under control. Rates change month to month with steel, cement and fuel prices, so treat every figure here as indicative and ask for dated quotes.
What a decent BOQ looks like
Ask each contractor, or your architect, for a BOQ with these sections:
- Excavation and foundation: depth, width, PCC thickness, and the mix ratio.
- Concrete work: footings, columns, beams, slabs, lintels and staircase, each with volume or area and the specified mix.
- Steel reinforcement: total weight in tonnes or kilograms, bar sizes, and grade. This is a major line and the easiest to under-supply.
- Masonry: brick or block quantity, wall thickness, and mortar ratio.
- Plaster: area, thickness and mix.
- Electrical and plumbing conduits: whether pipes and conduits are laid in the structure stage or left for later.
- Labour: rate per square foot or per item, and what is excluded.
- Items explicitly excluded: this part matters as much as what is included.
If a contractor says "we don't do BOQs, we work on trust," that is useful information about how disputes will go.
Check the quantities against a sanity range
You do not need to be an engineer to spot absurd numbers. Use the construction cost calculator to generate a ballpark for your plot size and finish, then use these rough sense-checks.
For a typical double-storey 5-marla house, the covered area is often in the region of 2,200 to 2,800 square feet across both floors, depending on design and basement. Grey structure rates for that kind of job commonly fall in a wide band that moves with city, specification and the date, so you should compare quotes with each other and with your own recent local enquiries rather than rely on a number from last year.
Then check the proportions. If the steel line in a quote is much lower than the others for the same drawings, ask why. Lower steel weight is the single most common way a low quote is produced, and it is the one defect you cannot see once the concrete has been poured. Ask your structural engineer, or an independent one, to compare the steel tonnage against the drawings.
The five lines where quotes quietly diverge
- Steel supply. Who supplies it, which grade, and is it weighed on site? Insist on delivery challans and keep them.
- Cement. Brand and bag count per slab. A contractor who "includes cement" without stating the quantity can quietly stretch it.
- Excavation and backfilling. Often left out, then billed at a high rate as soil is carted away or filled.
- Water and electricity for construction. Some quotes assume you provide them. Over six months this adds up.
- Curing, shuttering and scaffolding. Skimping on curing weakens concrete and costs nothing in the short term.
Write the answers into a comparison sheet with the same rows for each contractor. You will often find that the "cheaper" quote is missing two or three lines that bring it close to, or above, the rest.
Fixing the contract before you sign
A BOQ is only useful if it is attached to a contract. Make sure the agreement:
- Names the specifications and attaches the BOQ and drawings.
- Describes a payment schedule tied to milestones (foundation, ground slab, first-floor slab, roof) rather than calendar dates.
- States how variations are priced and that they need written approval before work begins.
- Fixes who supplies which materials, and what happens to leftover stock.
- Sets a retention, meaning a small percentage of the total held until a defects period passes.
- Includes a completion date and a clear consequence for delay.
If you are considering splitting labour and materials, think hard about who will carry the risk of wastage and delays. Labour-only arrangements can look cheaper, so price the wastage risk before you accept one.
Do a quick independent check before the slab
Even with a good BOQ, verification matters. Pay a structural engineer or experienced supervisor for a few site visits at the key moments: foundation steel before pour, column and beam steel before the roof slab, and the roof slab itself before concrete. A short visit before each pour costs a fraction of what a mistake will cost to fix afterwards.
Also keep your own record: dated photos of reinforcement before concrete, delivery slips for steel and cement, and a notebook of payments. If you plan to resell later, these records add credibility, and a buyer's engineer will appreciate seeing them.
A short example of reading two quotes
Suppose Quote A lists steel at 4.5 tonnes and Quote B lists 5.8 tonnes for the same drawings. The difference of 1.3 tonnes is not a rounding error; at market steel prices that can be several hundred thousand rupees (check today's rate per tonne), and it likely explains why A looks cheaper. Ask the structural engineer which number matches the drawings. Often, A will agree to raise its figure, and the quotes converge. Sometimes B is padding. Either way, you learn it before signing instead of during the pour.
Cement works the same way. Compare bag counts per slab rather than the rate per bag, because a lower rate with fewer bags is no saving at all.
Finishing items belong in a separate BOQ
Keep grey structure and finishing in separate documents. Tiles, woodwork, paint, sanitary fittings and electrical fixtures vary enormously in price depending on brand and taste, and a contractor who folds them into one number can hide almost any shortfall. For finishing, ask for a list of allowances, for example a per-square-foot tile allowance, so you can spend above or below it knowingly. That small habit prevents the classic argument where the "included" tiles turn out to be the cheapest on the market.
What to do this week
Collect two or three BOQs, put them in one sheet, and flag every line that is missing or oddly low. Call the contractors back with specific questions rather than asking for a "discount". You will usually get a more honest, more comparable number, and a clearer view of who has understood your plan. Use the construction cost calculator to sense-check the totals, and if you are still choosing a site or a plot size, the marla and kanal converter helps you work in consistent units. Then choose the contractor whose paperwork is clear, not the one whose number is lowest.
Frequently asked questions
What is a BOQ in house construction?
A bill of quantities is a line-by-line list of the work and materials for your build, with quantities, specifications and rates. It lets you compare contractor quotes on equal terms, and it stops hidden shortfalls in steel, cement or excavation from surfacing later as extra charges.
Why is one contractor's grey structure quote much cheaper?
The gap usually comes from material specification, not labour: less steel weight, fewer cement bags, shallower foundations or excluded items like excavation and curing. Compare the steel tonnage and cement bag counts against the drawings, and ask what each quote leaves out.
What should a construction contract include?
Attach the BOQ, drawings and specifications, tie payments to milestones, require written approval for variations, state who supplies which materials, hold back a small retention until a defects period ends, and fix a completion date with a consequence for delay.
Keep reading
Contractor payments in Pakistan: a 5 marla stage plan
Contractor asking for 40% upfront? Here is a milestone schedule for a 5 marla build, with retention and the clauses that keep your leverage.
8 Nov 2026 6 min read
Should you build during monsoon in Pakistan (2026)?
Monsoon build in Pakistan, 2026: real delays, cost cushions, safe RCC pours, curing days, and smart steel/cement buying—Lahore, Islamabad, Karachi specifics.
30 Jul 2026 9 min read
Labour-only construction contract Pakistan: is it worth it?
Mazdoori can save money if you manage the site, and cost more if you cannot. Here is how to compare quotes and write a clear deal.
29 Oct 2026 6 min read
