Rentable portion in a 5 marla house: cost vs rent check
You are building a 5 marla house in Lahore, Gujranwala or Faisalabad, and the architect asks one question that changes the budget: do you want a rentable portion upstairs, with its own entrance? Done well, a self-contained upper floor can pay a meaningful part of your instalments or retirement costs. Done badly, it is a flat nobody wants, with a staircase through your living room. The difference is mostly decided before the first brick, in the drawing.
Decide the portion before you finalise the plan
A rentable portion needs a private entry. If tenants must walk through your lounge or porch to reach the stairs, you will not rent it, or you will rent it to someone you resent within a month.
Plan for these from day one:
- A separate staircase door. Either an external staircase from the front or side, or an internal stair behind its own lockable door near the entrance. External stairs consume plot width, so check your setback rules.
- Separate electricity and gas connections. Apply for a separate meter for the portion if your utility allows it. Shared meters are a steady source of rent disputes.
- Separate water supply control. A second tank or at least a separate valve line, so one party cannot drain the other.
- A self-contained layout. Bedroom, bathroom, a small kitchen and a lounge. A one-bedroom portion with a proper kitchen rents more reliably than a two-bedroom with a corner stove.
Ask your architect to mark the portion's wiring, plumbing and drainage lines on a separate sheet. Retrofitting later is far more expensive than planning once.
What the extra floor costs
Construction rates change monthly with cement, steel, labour and fuel, and vary a lot between cities. The only honest approach is to build your own estimate. Open the construction cost calculator, enter your covered area, and compare the result with two written quotes from contractors using the same bill of quantities.
As a framework, split the cost of the portion into:
- Structure for the extra floor: slab, columns, brickwork or block, roof waterproofing. Because your foundation and ground-floor columns need to be designed for the extra load, tell your structural engineer now, not after the ground floor is done. Designing for a second floor from the start costs far less than strengthening later.
- Finishing: plaster, paint, tiles, doors, windows, kitchen cabinets, a bathroom set, electrical fittings.
- Services: separate meter fees, plumbing, water tank, a gas connection if available, and a basic geyser point.
- Extras tenants expect: a ceiling fan point, a wardrobe or at least a wall niche, and a kitchen counter.
Prices for these swing widely with quality. Use ranges from your own quotes and hold back a contingency, since a portion rarely comes in exactly on budget.
Estimate the rent honestly
Do not rely on what a neighbour "gets". Instead:
- Search comparable portions on Sakunat rentals in your exact area and note the asking rents for similar size and finish.
- Ask two local agents what portions actually rented for in the past six months, and how long they stayed vacant.
- Take the lower end of the range as your planning figure. Asking rent and achieved rent are rarely the same.
Then subtract costs. Gross rent is not income. Allow for vacancy, since even a good portion can sit empty for a month or two when tenants change, plus repairs, repainting between tenants, and your time. Use the rental yield calculator to put a number on the return after those costs.
A quick sanity check: divide the cost of building the portion by the monthly rent you can realistically expect. If the answer is a very long payback, you might be better off with a larger ground floor for your family or a cheaper finish. If it is a few years rather than a decade, the portion deserves its place in the plan.
Think about tenants before you choose finishes
Pick durable, boring finishes. Tenants do not value your imported tiles, and they will scratch them.
- Floors: simple tiles in neutral colours that are easy to replace.
- Kitchen: a granite or tile counter with a steel sink rather than costly cabinetry.
- Paint: washable emulsion in light colours, which is cheap to touch up.
- Heat and damp: insulate the roof above the portion and waterproof properly. A top-floor portion that bakes in summer or leaks in monsoon is hard to rent. Cross ventilation and a shaded window orientation cost nothing extra on paper.
Think also about who you want as tenants. A small family wants a safe entrance and a parking spot. A bachelor wants cheap rent and nothing else. Ask yourself which you prefer, and design for that person.
Mistakes I see on 5 marla sites
Three come up again and again. First, the staircase is added as an afterthought, so it eats the lounge or blocks the only window of the ground-floor bedroom. Second, the upper bathroom is stacked nowhere near the ground-floor plumbing, which means long drain runs that choke and leak into a ceiling. Third, owners skip roof waterproofing on the ground floor because "the upper floor will cover it", then discover seepage when the portion is already let. Fix these on paper and you will save more than any discount on cement.
Rules and paperwork to check first
Society and authority rules differ. Some schemes limit the number of floors or restrict separate entrances or commercial use. Before you commit:
- Read your society's or authority's building bylaws and approved plan conditions.
- Check height limits and whether a separate portion is allowed on your plot category.
- Confirm electricity connection rules for separate meters in your area.
If you plan to rent formally, prepare a written tenancy agreement and keep a record of the tenant's identity details, as local police verification rules apply in many areas. Check what applies where you live. Declare rental income as required, and ask a tax adviser what applies to you, since rules change and I would rather you confirm the current position than rely on an old figure.
A phased approach if cash is tight
If you cannot afford the whole house, there is a sensible compromise. Build the ground floor first, but design and reinforce for the upper floor: strong columns, a staircase position fixed, and a slab with provision for stairs. Stop at the roof of the ground floor, waterproof it properly, and plan to add the portion once you have saved, or once rent pressure makes it worthwhile.
Make sure your contractor leaves proper column starter bars protected from rust, and keep the drawings and engineer's notes safely, because the next contractor will need them. Check the old work before adding to it. Concrete that has aged for years needs inspection before a new floor loads it.
What to do this week
- Ask your architect for a plan showing a separate entrance, stair and services for the portion.
- Have your structural engineer confirm the design loads for two floors.
- Get two itemised quotes and compare them line by line.
- Check three local rents for comparable portions and write down the lowest.
- Run the numbers in the cost and yield calculators, and decide whether the portion earns its place.
If the numbers work, build it right. If they do not, you will have lost a few hours of planning rather than a few lakh rupees of concrete.
Frequently asked questions
Does a rentable portion need a separate entrance?
In practice yes. Tenants who must walk through your lounge or porch are hard to find and harder to live beside. Plan a separate staircase door, a lockable entry, and your own meters and water valve from the start, then check your society's bylaws on separate entrances and floors.
How do I estimate the rent a portion will earn?
Compare similar portions on rental listings in the same area, ask two local agents what they actually rented for recently and how long they stayed vacant, then plan with the lower end. Subtract vacancy, repairs and repainting before judging the return with a yield calculator.
Should I design for a second floor even if I build only the ground floor?
Yes, if you may add it later. Tell your structural engineer now so foundations and columns carry two floors, fix the staircase position, protect starter bars from rust, and keep the drawings. Strengthening later costs far more, and old concrete needs inspection before new loads.
Keep reading
Contractor payments in Pakistan: a 5 marla stage plan
Contractor asking for 40% upfront? Here is a milestone schedule for a 5 marla build, with retention and the clauses that keep your leverage.
8 Nov 2026 6 min read
Brick vs concrete block walls for a 5 marla house in Pakistan
Quotes say '9-inch brick everywhere'. Here is how to compare brick and block by finished cost, heat and site quality before the first course goes up.
14 Nov 2026 7 min read
Build a 5 marla house in phases: what to do first
Building a 5 marla house in stages saves cash only if you plan it. Know what must be done once and what can wait.
13 Nov 2026 6 min read
